“Are you sure that was with me?” Crossword Clue

We have the 5-letter answer for “Are you sure that was with me?” crossword clue, last seen in the New Yorker Crossword May 11, 2026 puzzle. Sometimes we all need some help finding the answer!

“Are you sure that was with me?” Crossword Answer

→58.

Find more clues, hints, and info below.

Hide

Find more clues, hints, and info below.

Helpful Hints

Hint 1: Clue Definition

SURE (adjective)
1. having or feeling no doubt or uncertainty; confident and assured
2. certain to occur; destined or inevitable
SURE (adverb)
1. definitely or positively (`sure’ is sometimes used informally for `surely’)

More New Yorker Crossword (5/11/2026) Answers

Across

1. Thin strip of wood

5. Shorthand Valentine’s message

10. Part of a dark cloud

14. Home of Lake Baikal and Lake Balkhash

15. National economic prosperity, so to speak

17. Performance venue that burned down in 1613

19. First book of Christopher Paolini’s “Inheritance Cycle”

20. "What are you waiting for?!"

21. Tell (on)

22. G and R, for two

24. Slim redesign of a two-thousands Nintendo handheld gaming system

26. “Money” author Martin

27. “Knavery’s plain face is never seen till used” speaker

30. North Carolina's __ Banks

31. Univ. near Covent Garden

32. Clicked

34. “Ugh, now?”

35. “I’m in no mood”

36. Common W.F.H. day

39. [Correct!]

41. Drop down?

42. Something that’s rushed

43. Take off the books

45. Brain parts that relay sensory input

47. Scary Spice or Sporty Spice, familiarly

48. Thirteenth-century Persian poet

51. Beats (up)

52. 2023 film based on Percival Everett’s “Erasure”

55. Occasions for hiring a sitter

56. Friend of Zoe and Abby Cadabby

57. Hardly jaded

59. Off! ingredient

All Answers

Down

1. Like some job moves, in corporate-speak

2. Religious hermitages

3. Employ the four-in-hand knot, perhaps

4. Robert Burns’s “great chieftain o’ the pudding-race”

5. 1999 animated film set during the Cold War, with “The”

6. ___ out (enthusiastically watch Kamala on “S.N.L.,” say)

7. Like some discounted purchases

8. Mona Lisa ___ ("My Cousin Vinny" role for Marisa Tomei)

9. Revealed, as spoiler text

10. Video-game franchise whose settings include Liberty City and Vice City, briefly

11. Sodium ___ (meat additive)

12. Price given on the spot?

13. Walk unsteadily

16. Begins tackling a problem

18. Chaney of “The Unholy Three”

23. One of “the most common and the most significant of all the perversions,” per Freud

25. What thirst traps inspire

28. Reach

29. “The King of Queens” actor Patton

32. Satsuma, e.g.

33. 1968 photograph taken by the Apollo 8 astronaut Bill Anders

34. Barrier used after a veterinary surgery

35. Exhaust

36. Warning on a box

37. Strongly emphasize

38. 'Nuh-uh!'

39. Force commanded by the seventh Duke of Medina-Sidonia

40. Southern granny

42. Groovy!

44. Like some dreams

46. Squad member from N.Y.C.

49. Yuletide trio

50. How many TV series air

53. Diamonds’ color

54. Celebratory initialism

All Answers